Pittsburgh's premiere murder mystery dinner events

Upcoming Events





Pittsburgh's premiere

murder mystery dinner company


Mystery Theatre Pittsburgh formerly known as McCaffery Mysteries, Inc. is Pittsburgh's premiere murder mystery entertainment company specializing in interactive murder mystery dinner shows.  Work together with your fellow table-mates to solve a murder mystery and see if you can figure out who committed the crime. We specialize in team building and problem solving workshops for corporate and schools in the tri-state area. We are also available for private parties, fundraising and special events. Click the "book" button above to learn more about booking a murder mystery dinner at your venue or next party.

Featured Mystery Dinners

Hear what our customers are saying

My husband and I have gone to quite a few murder-mystery-dinners, and when my now-11-year-old asked if she could have a "unique party," I immediately wondered if I would be able to find a show that was appropriate. We took a group of 17 kids and adults to see Elf'ed. There were enough silly jokes that the kids laughed non-stop, and enough jokes that went over their heads that kept the adults amused. The food was great. The actors were great. My daughter and her friends are still talking about the night.

My husband & I don't get out much without our kids and we make it a point to see a show every 6 months. They were wonderful - cast, storyline everything. I have recommended them & brought some couples with me. All enjoyed the show. They keep you engaged and laughing. I always go to the ones held at Gaetano's mainly because of the location but also like the food provided too. I look forward to more shows.

Sharon V, Pittsburgh, PA

Vicki D, Pittsburgh, PA

Murder Mystery Dinners?

Mystery Theatre Pittsburgh is Pittsburgh's Best Murder Mystery Dinner company with over 50 shows and over a decade of experience.